- Creatorland
- Posts
- š Creatorland #37 | The Dark Side of Influence, TikTok Ban News, and YouTubersā Revenue Strategies
š Creatorland #37 | The Dark Side of Influence, TikTok Ban News, and YouTubersā Revenue Strategies
Sydney Nicole Gifford's controversial lawsuit, the looming future of TikTok as it faces a choice between selling or shutting down, how YouTubers are expanding their revenue streams through AdSense, sponsorships, brand deals, and more.
š Hey hey Creatorland Community!
As we're wrapping up 2024 (how did that happen so fast?!), I've been reflecting on what an incredible year it's been. Watching this community grow - seeing new friendships form, deals come together, and careers take off - it's honestly the best part of my job. You all make this more than just a platform; you make it a community that's actually changing how the creator economy works.
Speaking of changes, a few quick updates from my world: I was recently invited to join Intro.co as an expert alongside some absolutely wild company (we're talking Alexis Ohanian co-founder of Reddit, Ali Webb co-founder of DryBar, and the founders of Zillow and Sweetgreen š¤Æ). I just shared the news on LinkedIn here and, you know, if you happened to drop by and show that post some love, I wouldn't hate it š in fact it would mean the world to me!
On the Creatorland front - wow! That super secret beta program we teased last week? The response has been INSANE. Hundreds of applications in just the last few days! While we're still accepting applications (grab yours here if you haven't already), spots are filling up fast. Learn more here.
Let's dive into what's new this week...
In todayās newsletter
š Lawsuit Drama - The Aesthetic Creator Copyright Case: Find out how influencers like Sydney Nicole Gifford are navigating claims of copyright infringement in the pursuit of originality and legal safety.
āļø Questions Creators Are Too Afraid to Answer: Ever wondered how much money top YouTubers actually makeāor what their biggest fears are? Hard Fork pulls back the curtain as creators answer.
š« Could The TikTok Ban Finally Happen: Will TikTok face its final days in the U.S.? Dive into the latest legal battles and how creators are preparing for the fallout.
š¤ DealSync Beta is taking off, and lorem ipsum
š„š Hot Ones Sold: Was It a Good Idea?
BuzzFeed just sold Hot Onesāthe wildly popular celebrity interview show featuring spicy wingsāfor $82.5 million. Sean Evans, the showās host, and Chris Schonberger, its founder, teamed up with an affiliate of Soros Fund Management to make the purchase.
But was it the right move? For BuzzFeed, itās part of a debt-reduction strategy as they shift focus to AI-driven content. For Hot Ones, it could mean exciting growthāor a risk of losing its original charm.
What are your thoughts? |
š° Creator Economy News
š§š»āāļøš«§ Amazon Influencers Face Lawsuit Over the āClean Girl Aestheticā
The "clean aesthetic girl" trend might not be as clean-cut as it looks.
Amazon influencers Sydney Nicole Gifford and Alyssa Sheil are facing a copyright lawsuit, accused of mimicking visuals and messaging from another creator's content.
Gifford is now forced to defend her brand. The plaintiff argues that her content is āsubstantially similarā to earlier work, which raises some tough questions for creators:
What actually counts as original when everyone is borrowing from the same trends?
How can influencers protect their work while staying relevant to viral aesthetics?
For creators, the big takeaways are clear:
When in doubt, credit: If you borrow visual or stylistic ideas, give a nod to the original creator. Itās not just politeāitās protective.
Know your rights: Trends are everywhere, but understanding fair use and copyright law is essential for long-term success.
This case could set a new precedent for creators who rely on trends to build their personal brands. For now, itās a reminder to stay creative, stay informed, and keep an eye on where inspiration ends and imitation begins.
For the full article, click here.
š¤š Questions YouTubers Are Too Afraid to Answer
Jay Clouse from Creator Science dives into the questions every creator dreads: How much do creators really make? Is the lifestyle sustainable? Jay and his producer, Conor, share raw, unfiltered insights into the highs and lows of the creator economy.
Episode Highlights:
Letās Talk $$$: The hosts break down real earnings, revealing $250,000 in sponsorships and AdSense over the year. But they also lay bare the hidden costs: āOn paper, it looks like Iām making a lot, but reinvesting into growth means Iām technically losing money on the channel,ā says Jay.
Behind the Sponsorship Curtain: Curious about rates? The podcast explains why creators charge $3,000+ per video, how bulk package deals boost revenue, and why renewal rates matter more than one-time payouts.
Remember: Creators who align with brandsā goals instead of just pitching standalone ads can drive higher returns and lock in long-term partnerships.
As Connor notes, āSponsors donāt just want a creatorāthey want someone who understands their business.ā
š“ ā¶ļø Will Trump Ban TikTok?
With the Protecting Americans from Foreign Adversaries Act (PAFCA) looming, Hard Fork break down the political and economic stakes of a potential TikTok ban and what it means for creatorsā.
What We Learned:
The Law That Could End It All: PAFCA, passed with bipartisan support, could force TikTokās parent company, ByteDance, to sell the appāor shut it down in the U.S. entirely. The hosts dive into the legal battle, including TikTokās failed appeals in the U.S. courts.
The Creatorās Dilemma: If TikTok disappears, whatās the backup plan? The episode highlights practical strategies for creators to diversify their platforms and prepare for disruption.
Whether youāre a TikTok creator or just curious about global tech rivalries, this episode has something for everyone.
š„ Hot Opportunities
šŗ Earn Extra Revenue with Mushy Media's Music Program
Mushy Media is inviting YouTube Shorts creators with over 2.5 million monthly views to join their music monetization program, allowing them to use licensed music tracks as background music while earning a tiered revenue share of up to 75%.
Was this newsletter forwarded to you? Subscribe Here
Not on Creatorland yet? Join Here.
š Happy Networking!
~ Brian F.
Content We Referenced Today:
Bad influence - The Verge
Questions YouTubers Are Afraid Of - Creator Science
Will Trump Ban TikTok? | EP 113 - Hard Fork (The New York Times)
Thinking about creating an online course? This app is a game changer
Course Creation Tool Made For Social Media Creators
100% Free, No subscription or monthly recurring payments
Expert Support to Get You Started